If a school district, a sports league, a staffing firm, or an employer withdrew an offer after a Peopletrail background check, the report behind that decision is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Peopletrail is a Utah screener with a long history and a documented dispute process, and the same law that lets it sell reports about you requires it to show you the report, reinvestigate what you dispute free of charge, and answer for what an error costs you.
What Peopletrail is
Peopletrail, LLC operates from Draper, Utah, south of Salt Lake City, and was incorporated in 2005 according to its Better Business Bureau profile and its own company history; it is privately held. Its site describes it as a PBSA-accredited consumer reporting agency, and it sells criminal-record searches, identity verification, employment and education verification, drug and health screening, driving records, I-9 and E-Verify processing, credit reports, social-media screening, international checks, and tenant screening to employers in construction, education, transportation, staffing, government, hospitality, healthcare, insurance, retail, and property management; youth-sports officiating bodies are among the organizations that publish its applicant contact sheet. When it assembles those records and sells them to an employer, it carries every duty the FCRA imposes.
Where these reports go wrong
A screener that pulls criminal records at volume fails in the ways criminal databases fail. A match on name and date of birth can attach a stranger’s felony to your file — the same failure that produces a mixed credit file; a charge that was dismissed can be reported as pending or as a conviction; an expunged record can surface from a database the court never updated; a non-conviction older than seven years can appear even though the FCRA bars it. Verification calls that go unanswered become “unable to verify,” which a hiring manager reads as a lie on the application.
If Peopletrail screened you for an apartment
Peopletrail also sells tenant screening, and the rules for a rental decision differ from the employment rules. A landlord has no duty to show you the report before deciding. But the Federal Trade Commission’s guidance to landlords treats denying the application, requiring a co-signer, requiring a deposit or a larger deposit than another applicant would pay, or charging more rent because of the report as adverse action that requires a notice. The notice must name the company that supplied the report and give its address and telephone number, state that the company did not make the decision and cannot give the specific reasons for it, and tell you that you may dispute the report and get a free copy if you ask within 60 days (15 U.S.C. § 1681m(a)). The free copy comes from § 1681j(b): a consumer reporting agency must make its disclosure without charge if you request it within 60 days of receiving that notice. Ask for it in writing, and dispute from the copy rather than from the landlord’s summary.
An E-Verify mismatch is not a final answer
Peopletrail also processes Form I-9 and E-Verify cases for employers, and a mismatch there can come from a records problem rather than an eligibility problem, such as a name change that never reached Social Security or a number entered wrong. E-Verify calls the result a tentative nonconfirmation. Under E-Verify’s published rules, the employer must notify you as soon as possible, within 10 federal government working days, and review the Further Action Notice with you in private. If you decide to resolve it, you contact the Social Security Administration or the Department of Homeland Security within eight federal government working days of the referral. While the case is open, the employer may not terminate or suspend you, delay your training or start date, withhold or lower your pay, or take any other adverse action because of the mismatch, until it becomes a final nonconfirmation. If an employer acted on a mismatch before you had the chance to contest it, keep the notice and the dates.
How to get your report and dispute it
Peopletrail publishes a full dispute channel. According to its privacy policy and applicant-support pages, and the contact sheet employers hand to applicants, disputes go by phone to (866) 223-8822 or (801) 307-4100, by email to support@peopletrail.com, by fax to 888-759-7037, or by mail to Peopletrail, LLC, Attn: Consumer Protection Department, 65 E. Wadsworth Park Drive, Suite 102, Draper, UT 84020. The company says it acknowledges a dispute within five business days and completes the reinvestigation within 30 days, which the FCRA can extend by 15 days if you send new information during the investigation. A copy of your own report is available on request through the same support address, and the employer that ordered it must give you a copy before taking adverse action. Dispute in writing, attach the court disposition or records that prove your point, and keep every letter and reply; our guide to disputing a background check covers what the letter should say.
When it becomes a legal claim
Consumer reporting agencies must follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy, reinvestigate disputes, and delete what they cannot verify. A stranger’s record on your report, a dismissed charge reported as a conviction, or a dispute that changes nothing is the exact failure the FCRA makes compensable: actual damages for the job you lost, statutory and punitive damages where the violation is willful, and attorney’s fees, which is why we handle these cases on contingency. Peopletrail sits alongside AccuSourceHR, Truescreen, and the other companies in our background check company directory — and our background check error lawyer practice covers the rest, from when you can sue a screening company to what a rescinded job offer is worth.
Rated by the Clients We Represent
Richard Kim is rated 10.0 out of 10 on Avvo, with 35 client reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5 stars (as of September 2026) — read the reviews on Avvo. Admitted in Pennsylvania and New Jersey; available to appear pro hac vice in other federal courts. You pay nothing unless we win.
Published by The Kim Law Firm, LLC — about attorney Richard Kim. Last updated October 2026.